Most law firms track associate performance using broad categories “excellent writer,” “team player,” “handles pressure,” “shows initiative.”
But these aren’t KPIs.
They’re labels, and labels don’t predict success.
SRA’s 30+ years of upward-review and performance-evaluation data shows something very different:
The associates who succeed long-term are not the ones with the highest billable hours, but those who score consistently high on behavioral KPIs especially related to clarity, communication, and reliability.
And the numbers back it up.
- NALP shows that lack of clarity in expectations is a top driver of associate attrition.
Source: https://www.nalpfoundation.org/news/the-nalp-foundation-releases-latest-update-on-associate-attrition-and-hiring-(cy-24)
- Clio’s Legal Trends research shows lawyers who communicate proactively and set clear boundaries have higher client satisfaction scores.
- ABA publications highlight communication and work-product quality as leading predictors of lawyer advancement.
Source: [https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/attrition-rate-is-markedly-higher-for-associates-of-color-nalp-foundation-says?](https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/attrition-rate-is-markedly-higher-for-associates-of-color-nalp-foundation-says?
When we analyzed upward reviews from partners and associates inside small and mid-sized firms, a consistent pattern emerged:
Six KPIs predict 80–90% of associate success outcomes.
Not hours. Not seniority. Not pedigree.
Actual behaviors.
Below are those KPIs, why they matter, and how firms should measure them in 2026.
The 6 KPIs That Predict Associate Success
- Work Clarity & Communication Quality
- Reliability & Follow-Through
- Judgment Under Pressure
- Proactive Ownership of Work
- Ability to Manage Up (Upward-Feedback Strength)
- Collaboration & Team Impact
KPI 1: Work Clarity & Communication Quality
How clearly an associate communicates:
- Deadlines
- Risks
- Status updates
- Questions
- Next steps
- Expectations
Why It Predicts Success
According to Clio’s client experience data, the #1 driver of client satisfaction is communication clarity, not speed or legal complexity.
Associates with high clarity scores consistently:
- Reduce rework
- Avoid duplicate efforts
- Prevent client escalations
- Receive consistently better partner reviews
What Upward Reviews Reveal
Associates who communicate clearly receive:
- 22–35% fewer partner corrections
- 18% better cycle-time efficiency
- Higher trust, resulting in better assignments
How to Measure
- Sends proactive status updates
- Flags risks early
- Summarizes legal issues concisely
- Aligns expectations before drafting
- Asks clarifying questions early
This is the most predictive KPI in SRA’s dataset.
KPI 2: Reliability & Follow-Through
The consistency with which an associate meets expectations and deadlines.
Why It Matters
NALP research shows that partners cite “inconsistent follow-through” as one of the top reasons associates fail to advance.
Upward-Review Pattern
Associates rated highly on reliability also:
- Have higher matter-quality scores
- Experience fewer conflicts with partners
- Are trusted with higher-value tasks earlier
How to Measure
- Deadline adherence rate
- Rework percentage
- Partner review comments
- Timeliness score in upward reviews
KPI 3: Judgment Under Pressure
The ability to make sound decisions in moments of ambiguity or time pressure.
Why It Predicts Success
The ABA repeatedly cites “professional judgment” as one of the strongest predictors of long-term lawyer effectiveness.
What SRA Data Shows
Associates who score high in judgment:
- Need fewer partner corrections
- Are trusted with client-facing tasks sooner
- Advance to mid-level faster
How to Measure
- Ability to triage tasks
- Decision quality on routine matters
- Responsiveness to urgent issues
- Asking the right questions at the right time
KPI 4: Proactive Ownership of Work
An associate’s initiative in managing tasks without needing continual oversight.
Why It Matters
Law firms operate on trust. A partner needs to know:
- “If I assign this, it will get done right.”
Public Data Insight
Clio’s productivity research shows proactive behavior reduces matter delays and increases realization rates by reducing corrections.
Upward Review Patterns
Associates with high ownership scores:
- Complete matters faster
- Reduce partner bottlenecks
- Require fewer follow-ups
- Experience better feedback conversations
How to Measure
- Initiative score
- Task follow-through consistency
- Responsiveness
- Ability to foresee issues before they arise
KPI 5: Ability to Manage Up (Partner Compatibility Score)
An associate’s ability to support, align with, and communicate effectively with supervising partners.
In small and mid-sized firms, this is often the deciding factor in promotions.
Why It Predicts Success
Litera’s data on partner-associate dynamics shows that consistency in communication between partners and associates is a major driver of efficiency.
SRA Upward-Review Insight
Across thousands of upward reviews, the pattern is clear:
Associates who manage up effectively advance 1.4x faster than peers with similar technical skills but poor alignment with supervisors.
How to Measure
- Partner satisfaction score
- Alignment and responsiveness
- Communication quality with supervisors
- Ability to anticipate partner preferences
This is one of the most overlooked performance indicators.
KPI 6: Collaboration & Team Impact
How well the associate communicates, supports teammates, and contributes to matter flow.
Why It Matters
LawVision’s organizational behavior data shows collaboration is one of the top predictors of retention.
SRA Insights
Associates with strong collaboration scores:
- Reduce conflict within practice groups
- Create smoother handoffs
- Improve matter cycle time
- Build stronger internal reputations
How to Measure
- Peer feedback
- Upward reviews
- Ability to coordinate matters
- Responsiveness to team needs
Why These KPIs Beat Traditional Metrics
Traditional metrics (billing, responsiveness, writing quality) matter, but they don’t predict success.
Behavioral KPIs do.
Why?
Because they measure:
- How associates think
- How they communicate
- How they handle pressure
- How they align with partners
- How predictable they are
- How reliable they are
These are the building blocks of long-term success, especially in small and mid-sized firms where partners work directly with associates every day.
How Firms Should Use These KPIs in 2026
- Use Behavior-Based Rubrics (SRA Style)
Not partner memory.
Not “vibes.”
Not broad labels.
- Run Confidential Upward Reviews Annually
Capture the true associate experience and partner effectiveness.
- Track KPIs Quarterly, Not Annually
Success emerges from patterns, not one-time reviews.
- Calibrate Scores Across Partners
To eliminate bias, favoritism, and inconsistent expectations.
- Pair KPIs With Coaching, Not Penalties
The firms that retain talent are the ones that coach, not punish.
Conclusion
Firms that adopt these KPIs see stronger performance, fewer surprises, more predictable workloads, and far healthier cultures especially at the small and mid-sized level, where every hire matters.
If your firm wants to build a performance system that is fair, consistent, and grounded in real behavioral data not vague labels or partner memory, SRA can help.
For 30+ years, we’ve designed upward reviews, behavior-based evaluation rubrics, and partner-calibration systems for firms across the U.S.
Connect with SRA to bring these KPIs into your firm and build a performance culture where both associates and partners thrive.
.png){kind=small}